Estonian government and its lawyers, incl. those at Human Rights Court have successfully cheated European Human Rights Court, including EHRC section 2 president ROBERT SPANO from Iceland and even Judges from Denmark and Monaco (and Turkey and Albania and Moldova) to use fake claims and fake papers (compiled months after death of 26-year old Oliver Rõigas, victim of tremendous hospital abuse in autumn 2009). Those fake papers are not valid without required stamps, all done to cover up murder, brutal abuse, massive involuntary drugging, including with hazardous psychiatric drugs like Haloperidol (read below how UN experts label it as torture drug). The
torture with psychotropic drugs, including Haloperidol started after
one week in the hospital after we had agreed up switch of the hospital
and former communist Dr. Aadu Liivat
- family friend to Estonian Human Rights Court judge Julia Laffranque,
daugther of communist psychiatrist - appeared to duty and ordered nurses
to administer those hazardous drugs and lock Oliver Rõigas hands to bed.
Oliver Rõigas had gone to hospital for tests only, he had no pain and was not asking neither given any painkillers during first week after being signed into hospital on 24 September 2009. He had went to hospital to find out why he had got sudden severe balance and eye problems after his short visit to Estonian biggest hospital on 19 September 2009 where he had been administered Cerucal (Metoclopramide) without his informed consent. It was only in 2014 that I learned from the warning by European Medicines Agency about Metoclopramide (Cerucal) that the symptoms he had developed were similar to that drug possible severe side effects, known to doctors for long. Instead of telling this to us, Oliver Rõigas fall a victim of massive secret drugging, torture, overdoses and murder and as his medical records hint also drug hunting.
European HUMAN RIGHTS COURT JUDGEMENT DISTRIBUTES FAKE BRAIN DEATH CLAIM
All valid medical records require to have a special stamp that contains name of patient, hospital case number and patient ID on it. Not a single paper or document compiled during O.R. stay at Tallinn hospital has any such paper/document about determing or even starting to determine brain death that is a process with several procedures carried out by different doctors. Such sealing with stamp is needed to avoid post-mortal falsification and creation of new papers into medical records.
Among completely false claims, incorporated into European Human Rights Court September 12, 2017 judgement and signed by Judge ROBERT SPANO releasing Estonian government from responsibility of violating EHRC articles 2 (right to life and also 3 (torture) and 8 is completely false claim that when O.R. was left without food, water and any drugs, including antibiotics (even that he had two side bacterial pneumonia) since morning Oct. 13, 2009 he was "brain dead" despite not a single document (!!!) confirming or even noting brain death was made neither on Oct 13 or Oct 14 or Oct 15 2009 and was not mentioned because of that also in final summary medical document - compiled on Oct 15 2009 after his death when his ventilator was switched off few hours after his mother was forced to leave shortly before midnight Oct 14/15 2009.
Oliver Rõigas had needed ventilator since the evening of 12 October 2009 after several simultanously administered heart affecting
drugs by Russian nurse (without any written order by any doctor in
medical records despite the administration of those drugs is confirmed in Estonian Forensic Science Institute August 2012 Expert act. All these drugs were administered without any informed consent from O.R. or next to kin at hospital - Mother.
Without EVER requesting Applicant - Mother - to answer on which days exactly she was legal representative of her son Human Rights Court section 2 has misleadingly published a false claim that Mother didnt not respond to this government claim! Instead of taking a tremendous violation of human rights seriously as it might point to many more victims in Estonian hospitals where Soviet era practice to administer drugs without informed consent has been still ongoing Court section 2, vice chaired by Estonian judge misleads the public. Namely - next to kin is next to kin at the hospital and request to ask consent from next to kin (in case patient has not chosen legal representative or signed a document to allow to administer whatever doctors and nurses want) and he or she is sedated, in coma or otherwise unable to express will is set in law and not for under age relatives only.
European Human Rights Court section 2 judgement, signed by judge Robert Spano also completely misleads public when its helping Estonian government out of shame for using hazardous psychiatric drugs at government supervised hospital - like Haloperidol, administered secretly and several times to O.R. since 3 October 2009 after we had agreed up transfer to other hospital. The transfer was cancelled on 7 October 2009 when shortly before I had arrived to hospital Oliver was sedated with Fentanyl. The administration of all those hazardous drugs emerged years after Oliver´s murder at the hospital and was confirmed in list of drugs administered by Estonian Forensic Science Institute in August 2012. After police had declined to open criminal case and order order independent autopsy on 15 October 2009 it took half year after criminal case was finally launched in April 2010 and thereafter it took another two years (two years) after Prosecution asked to compile an expertise that was requested to be done without any independent test, only by the papers compiled by doctors involved.
Misleading public Human Rights Court section 2 September 12, 2017 judgement is not even mentioning administration of psychiatric drugs, including Haloperidol to O.R. despite administration of Haloperidol has been confirmed by Estonian Forensic Science Insitute in its expert act in August 2012. (Look at evidence of this and other hazardous drugs below).
GOVERNMENT OWN EXPERTS CONFESSED 2014 THAT drugs IMPACT WAS NOT EVEN EVALUATED
Human Rights Court judgement made in favor of Estonian Government that cheated the Court with fake claims and fake papers during the time when case was sitting under Turkish judge Isil Karakas and vice chair Estonian Julia Laffranque also completely misleads the public with claim that investigation into case closed in autumn 2012 was sufficient because Deputy Director of Estonian Forensic Science Institute pathologist Ms Marika Väli who compiled the only valid expert act in this criminal case that the prosecutor request in winter 2012 - TWO YEARS AFTER CASE WAS FINALLY OPENED in 2010 confessed in written in May 2014 that the impact of drugs and their doses and whether they were needed, incl Haloperidol and massive daily amount of Dexamethasone daily to O.R (neither his or his mothers consent was ever asked) w e r e n o t evaluated during expertise.
The requests by lawyer of Oliver Rõigas' Mother Mr. Rainer Kuulme to reopen the criminal case - based on Marika Väli confession - was declined in 2014 by prosecution that had helped to cover up the abuse and murder and the request to reopne the case was declined also by Court, incl Supreme Court, chaired by PRIIT PIKAMÄE, also ad hoc judge to EHRC in 2017.
The EFSI deputy head confession letter from May 2014 was submitted to Human Rights Court in 2015.
BRUTAL HOSPITAL ABUSERs FAMILY is FAMILY FRIEND TO ESTONIAN HUMAN RIGHTS COURT JUDGE JULIA LAFFRANQUE, BORN JULIA VAHING
Estonian lawyers, including European Human Rights Court Judge Julia Laffranque, deputy head of the section where the case of 26-year old torture and murder victim Oliver Rõigas had been delivered and ad hoc judge Madis Ernits mislead and cheated EUROPEAN HUMAN RIGHTS COURT TO USE FAKE claims and fake papers knowingly because in difference of non Estonian judges they have seen all evidence and medical records in Estonian.
Several fake claims, including fake "brain death" claim was compiled in 2010 by Estonian Health board inspector, known to have been closely KGB related during Soviet occupation Peeter Mardna, co-student of Judge Laffranque Soviet psychiatrist father Vaino Vahing at same medical department in 50s and 60s.
Judge Laffranque fellow judges at Human Rights Court have completely ignored administration of psychotropic drugs and even note in judgement that restraining the 26 year old who had fallen victim of unimaginable chemical torture by Judge Laffranque family friend was "apparently" to avoid causing him harm himself.
The Court judgment from September 12, 2017 completely lacks the reference to confirmed list of hazardous drugs from only valid expertise carried out in this criminal case appealed to EHRC in 2013 and confirming among other things the administration of Haloperidol that UN experts have outlined as torture drug. Instead judge Laffranque colleagues from department she vice chairs at Human Rights Court site a fake claims abd fake paper from 2010 as expertise, compiled at Social Ministry in 2010 after police had declined to open investigation on October 15, 2009. The Health Board 2010 arranged fake paper is signed only by former PERH employee Peeter Mardna, deputy head of Expert Committee on the Quality of Health Care Services who studied medicine in 1950s and 60s together with Judge Julia Laffranque psychiatrist father and not just ignored but also faked in spring 2010 the evidence from medical records.
In difference of that 2010 fake "expertise" sited at EHRC press release the only valid expertise in this criminal case, compiled in August 2012 by Estonian Forensic Science Institute:
- EFSI confirmed (page 3 of the EFSI 2012 expert act) that Oliver Rõigas had been administered Cerucal (Metoclopramide), during his short visit to hospital on September 19, 2009,
-EFSI confirmed (pages 3 and 7) that before returning to hospital on September 24, 2009 after getting balance and eye problems (possible side effects of Cerual) O.R. had taken only 0.5-1 mg (1-2 pills) Dexamethasone, increased 24-48 x - to 24 mg daily at the hospital,
-EFSI confirmed that after O.R. pneumonia was diagnosed on 6 October 2009 he was administered hazardous drugs Haloperidol, Propofol (page 7)
-EFSI confirmed that O.R. was sedated with Fentanyl since 7 October 2009 (page 8),
- EFSI confirmed that on 12 October 2009 when O.R. fell into coma he had been administered several blood lowering and heart affecting drugs simultanously and before that twice Clopheline (page 8) , etc. etc.
For none of these hazardous drugs informed consent was asked neither got and Human Rights Court section 2 did not see even a problem in it.
In autumn 2009 my son, 26-year old Oliver Rõigas fell a victim of massive secret involuntary drugging with hazardous substances like Haloperidol (several times, the most massive amount - 20 mg in two hours), Xanax, Propofol, Fentanyl, Clophelin and several other hazardous drugs (the administration of those drugs has been confirmed by Estonian Forensic Science Institute Expert ACT 2012) after he had developed breathing and speech problems at the hospital in his first week there and I had agreed up transfer to other hospital, as both I and my son suspected that something had gone wrong.
Haloperidol alone is a real torture drug:
"Haldol (Haloperidol) gained notoriety in the Soviet Union, where it was often given to political dissidents imprisoned in psychiatric hospitals. "In the history of oppression, using haloperidol is kind of like detaining people in Abu Ghraib, the infamous prison in Iraq, said Nigel Rodley, who teaches international human rights law at the University of Essex in Britain and is a former United Nations special investigator on torture.
For people who are not psychotic, said Philip Seeman, a University of Toronto specialist in psychiatry and pharmacology, "prescribing Haldol . . . is medically and ethically wrong." Seeman studied the drug in the 1960s and later discovered the brain receptors on which several antipsychotic drugs work." Washington Post, May 18, 2008 (link to article below).
More about the case and how Estonian government cheated the Human Rights Court
It
was only last year in 2016 when I learned that European Human Rights Court judge Julia Laffranque (nominated to Court by PM Andrus ANSIP, (former cimmunist party official in Tartu) whose officials had launched the cover up) is herself a daughter of Soviet era communist psychiatrist and FAMILY
FRIEND TO THE former Tartu communist doctor AL who had been giving to nurses
illegal orders to administer Haloperidol, Xanax etc to my son Oliver
Rõigas. Judge Laffranque's mother in turn is also close to the
politician son of doctor AL with whom they together were also involved
in election campaign in same Tallinn district as candidates from Social
Democratic Party.
One of the key persons in Estonian government involved in cheating Human Rights Court with submitting false data and requesting illegal fake 2010 spring "expertise" to be used is Ms HELEN TRALLA, head of legal department at Social Ministry during 2015 and 2016 when Estonian government compiled and submitted fake papers and fake claims to Court - one in winter 2015 that we were allowed to comment and one in summer 2015 that we were not allowed to comment after Turkish lawyer at Court informed my lawyer in written that our request to comment government July 2015 claims is declined. No wonder because Ms Helen Tralla too is closely related to deputy head of the section Estonian Judge Julia Laffranque - namely in 2010 Ms Laffranque supervised master thesis of Helen Tralla.
Among other persons helping to cover up the case are also some Ms Laffranque former colleagues from Estonian Supreme Court, that first under its head Märt Rask and then under Priit Pikamäe blocked the requests to reopen the investigation of the criminal case that my lawyer had repeatedly requested over the years. The Supreme Court that obviously has wished to save the image of lower level judges abd prosecutors who helped government to cover up the case even declined to allow to evaluate in domestic court separate case on how health officials under former KGB related doctor Peeter Mardna faked in 2010 the evidence at Social Ministry. Once again, no wonders - former communist doctor Mardna was a fellow student of Judge Laffranque father at Tartu University medical department in 50s and 60s when informed consent was not requested and drugs like Haloperidol was used as torture drug to silence political dissidents during Soviet rule.
Judge Julia Laffranque who finally resigned from the case in spring 2017 (but all fake data remained in file) and anyone else involved in cheating the Human Rights Court other judges have not only caused completely unnessary additional suffering to me as a Mother of Oliver who was poisoned, brutally abused and murdered in the hospital. Delay and false data used to silence the case has enabled those responsible for this brutality to keep working behind the closed doors of hospital and one can only guess how many more victims have there been. The recent case in Germany where already jailed nurse is suspected of deaths of over 80 patients and some similar cases from other countries have indicated that involuntary drugging with hazardous drugs can cause huge amount of victims when the cases are not taken seriously.
MASSIVE AND FATAL ADMINISTRATION OF DRUGS WITHOUT INFORMED CONSENT AT TALLINN BIGGEST HOSPITAL PERH
My son who had had nice trip to Stockholm with his friends earlier same month September 2009 ended up on 24 September 2009 at NEMC/PERH neurosurgery department not because his health suddenly worsened as Court wrongly claims on his website BUT BECAUSE OLIVER RÕIGAS WAS ADMINISTERED WITHOUT HIS INFORMED CONSENT METOCLOPRAMIDE (Cerucal) during his visit to NEMC hospital on Sept 19, 2009. We returned to additional tests 5 days later because he had developed horrible side effects since Sept 20, including balance problems that he had never had in his life before and that is one possible side effect of Metoclopramide but we did not know it because in Estonian drug sheet it was not written. Oliver Rõigas ended up at neurosurgery department when we returned on Sept 24 only because father of his classmate - Dr ALAR LAKS - is from the same department and we had called Dr Laks for advice what to do after Oliver had developed horrible neurological symptoms after his Sept 19 visit to the same hospital.
Oliver agreed to stay at the hospital on 24 September 2009 only for few days for tests and neither he or me had any idea that he will fall a victim since day first to massive secret involuntary poisoning, brutal abuse and murder by dr. Alar Laks roommate Aadu Liivat. Oliver had had several ticks on body that summer and suspected also tick related illnesses and we had requested relevant tests already on Sept 19 but these were never made. When Oliver was signed to hospital on 24 September he had no pain, did not ask and did not get any painkillers neither that day or later at regular care unit but hospital nurse started to sedate him without his knowledge every evening and to administer huge amount of Dexamethasone that can cause oedema/swelling - the direct cause of his death at death certificate 3 weeks later.
After been sedated with Zopitin secretly every evening since first evening at hospital Sept 24, 2009 as medical records confirm and administered every day secretly a huge dose of Dexamethasone that exceeded former pre-hospital daily dose (0,5 mg) 48 times (24 mg every day) my son and I agreed up with his treating doctor ML to change the hospital after weekend 3-4 October 2009. But during that weekend doctor AL, family friend to judge Julia Laffranque and being a doctor whom we had never met before had appeared to duty and one of the nurses started to secretly insert into Oliver horrible brain affecting drug Haloperidol already on Saturday and since Sunday also Xanax, his both hands were locked to bed and I was warned by dr AL that if I do not obey the orders of staff I will be kicked out and will never see my son again.
On Monday it turned out that treating doctor ML whom we had seen last on Friday had gone suddenly to holiday. On Tuesday October 6 after untreated two side bacterial pneuminia was diagnosed Oliver was administered secretly also Propofol several times in addition to massive amount of Haloperidol (both contradicted to patients with breathing problems) And on night between Tuesday and Wednesday, just few hours before I came Wednesday morning to finally switch the hospital Oliver had been secretly sedated with one of the strongest narcotic substance Fentanyl and the transfer to other hospital was cancelled by new treating doctor who had taken over on Tuesday when untreated two side bacterial pneumonia had been diagnosed by new treating doctor.
Without having any idea about the fact that horrible drugs had been secretly administered to Oliver PERH staff lied that the condition of Oliver had worsened due to other reason. After postponing and cancelling all my attempts to leave the hospital as Oliver wished he was then administered secretly and simultanously several blood pressure lowering drugs on evening October 12, 2009 by Russian nurse that was followed half an hour later with the start of irregular breathing, then rapid decline of blood pressure and then coma that all happened in front of my eyes without me having any idea what the Russian nurse had secretly inserted into my son. Since next morning Oliver was left against my requests without any food and without any antibiotics despite been diagnosed on 12 day in hospital with two side bacterial pneumonia, and brutally murdered. No brain determination protocol was even started and ever compiled. The Court claim that about brain death on 13 October is completely wrong - this "white sheet of paper" has even no Oliver name on it.
It was only 5 years later in 2014 when I learned that the former communist doctor from Tartu who had been giving horrible drug orders to nurses on that weekend 3-4 October 2009 when administration of Haloperidol and Xanax started without Oliver´s or mine consent had been giving illegal drug orders to nurses already during Oliver´s first week at hospital, despite he was not treating doctor and we were even not aware about that person at all.
Over the years it emerged that there was no medical plan at all, in some cases Russian nurse had inserted hazardous drugs and overdoses without any order by any doctor in medical records at all, etc.etc.
AFTER PLAN TO SWITCH HOSPITAL REVEALED TORTURE WITH PSYCHOTROPIC DRUGS HALOPERIDOL ETC AND HANDS LOCKING FOLLOWED. LATER -MASSIVE COVER UP BY AUTHORITIES.
Massive cover-up by Estonian government has followed. Despite the administration of those hazardous drugs listed above was confirmed from medical records in August 2012 by expert act of Estonian Forensic Science Institute Estonian authorities decided to ignore the facts from medical records and submitted massive amount of false data to European Human Rights Court in 2015, seemingly not understanding that the practice of massive involuntary secret drugging that emerged in this tragedy points to unknown number of victims in the hospital still supervised by Soviet era trained doctors who told even to police that medical staff has a right to insert whatever they wish to someone´s body without a consent.
When Oliver and I visited the Tallinn PERH hospital on 19 September 2009 asking tick-borne test hospital refused to do the test and only CT on head instead was made that found nothing unnormal. But during that visit to hospital Oliver was secretly administered into veins Metoclopramide (Cerucal) that can cause horrible neurological side effects. He was then wrongly prescribed and ordered without informed consent to take Metoclopramide (Cerucal) also at home every day.
Already next day 20 September 2009 Oliver´s one eye suddenly changed position, he got severe rash on face and developed also balance problems. When he and I returned to PERH hospital on 24 September 2009 to find out what has happened massive secret drugging started. We had no idea that Metoclopramide can cause balance problems because the drug information in Estonia did not mention it.
Oliver had had a tumour operation in that same hospital in April 2009 and after his brutal torture, poisoning and murder in autumn 2009 the hospital rewrote the April 2009 tumour description with new words by another doctor (sample number in both descriptions is same), presented it falsely with autopsy date from October 16, 2009 and Estonian government submitted also this false document to Human Rights Court together with several other lies.
You can click here for details, photocopy of confirmed list of drugs administered, all facts about drugs and doses are from the medical records. The horrible tragedy with all evidence shows that several Soviet era trained doctors and some nurses and younger doctors they supervise still consider it normal that people who enter hospitals loose even their basic human rights. Those Soviet era doctors and Estonia´s government officials and prosecutors saw even no problem in fact that immediately after we had agreed up the transfer from PERH hospital Oliver was secretly administered horrible brain affecting Haloperidol. Haloperidol was used by Soviet era doctors to torture and silence political dissidents (read Washington Post article from link about Haloperidol below).
The Estonian government and prosecutors saw also no problem in overdoses, violation of drug information list guidelines, and in fact that this tragedy revealed how people are allocated in at least some Estonian hospital to various medical procedures against their will, their freedom can be taken with their hands locked to bed and people can even fall a victim of homicide in hospital.
Despite all the evidence that emerged from medical records the politicians, health officials and law officials of Estonia do their best to cover up such cases and harass the people who have outlined the lack of law and the severe violation of basic human rights in Estonian health care system. According to Estonian Patients Advocacy Association and Human Rights Centre report 2012 hospital abuse and violation of human rights and even torture are serious problems in some Estonian hospitals.
The brutal abuse, poisoning and murder of Oliver Rõigas was appealed to European Human Rights Court on July 23, 2013. The Human Rights Court sent a letter with questions on December 2, 2014 to Estonian government, opening proceedings to find out whether the European Human Rights Convention was violated. In spring 2015 and July 2015 government submitted its responses full of tremendous lies, faked claims, presented as "facts" and even started to ignore the list from medical records about the horrible drugs administered that was also confirmed by Estonian Forensic Science Institute in its expert act in August 2012.
When I turned to Human Rights Court in summer 2013 I sincerely hoped that the tragedy of my son and the details and evidence that emerged from medical records will not bring only some kind of justice to me with my Oliver but that it will fundamentally change the way how people are treated in Estonian hospitals, still supervised by Soviet era trained doctors. By January 2017 Human Rights Court has not yet even asked Estonian government why Oliver Rõigas was tortured with Soviet era torture drug Haloperidol or why Oliver Rõigas was tortured with his hands locked to bed for days while he was secretly administered hazardous drugs without his consent or mine consent during the time when he had been sedated or later in coma and I was his only legal representative as only next to kin at hospital.
NEARLY 8 YEARS LATER: QUALITY REPORT OUTLINES NEARLY TWICE BIGGER POST-OP DEATH RATE AT PERH. NONE OF THE STAFF WHO ABUSED AND DRUGGED OLIVER RÕIGAS WITHOUT INFORMED CONSENT PUNISHED or made respinsible in any way
Few months after I turned to Human Rights Court in 2013 special council to determine health care quality indicators and evaluate quality in different hospitals was set up by medical department of Tartu University and government institution responsible for health care financing. According to the 164 page report released by the council In late July 2017 even the 30 day post-operational mortality rate at PERH/NEMC hospital is nearly twice bigger (over 7 percent) than at the other highest level hospital in Southern Estonian town Tartu (4%) and in Europe as average (also 4 percent together with Eastern Europe). However, for Estonian government and lawyers, including several Estonian lawyers sent to Human Rights Court the cover up of the case has been more important than the safety of patients.
ps. I found out that Human Rights Court judge is a daugther of Soviet psychiatrist after I started to look for the reason in 2016 why the section at the Court she is deputy head of has not even asked Estonian government why psychiatric drugs like Haloperidol etc were secretly administered to my son at NEMC/PERH hospital despite administration of those drugs is confirmed in August 2012 expert act compiled by Estonian Forensic Science Institute. I then found out that most KGB related psychiatrist in Soviet Estonia in times wheb Haloperidol was used to torture political dissidents in Soviet Union was head of Tartu psychiatric hospital Mr Jüri Saarma who had published several books together with someone called VAINO VAHING. When I then searched internet for Soviet psychiatrist Vaino Vahing I learned that he is father to JULIA VAHING, Julia Laffranque. Judge Laffranque father also worked at Tartu University medical department in 1980s when several persons, including AL studied at same department and learned among other things Soviet psychiatry in era when drugging without informed consent and use of Haloperidol to abuse political dissidents was common in Soviet Union.
During the time when my son was brutally abused and murdered in autumn 2009 and the case was covered up by government officials Estonian government was lead by current Vice President of European Commission Andrus Ansip, former Communisty Party official from Tartu, communist party fellow in Tartu in 80s and 90 of both judge Laffranque father and doctor AL, the main person behind the tremendous hospital abuse and murder of my 26-year old son Oliver Rõigas.
I have spent over 7 years of my life to stop or at least decrease the ongoing practice from Soviet era to administer hazardous drugs without informed consent. Its disgraceful to harass and humiliate victims with false claims and fake papers just to save the image of someone's friend or colleagues when human lives are on stake.
For more details about the abuse and murder in Tallinn PERH hospital in 2009 please click here.
Anneli Rõigas
Contact:
+372 5511910,
Email: annelibox@yahoo.com
Fake 2010 expert paper was requested to be added to Human Rights Court case file by Estonian lawyer PEETER ROOSMA
We did not submit the fake 2010 expertise to Court with Application in July 2013 but noted it to show how officials lied. The fake document compiled in Social Ministry was requested from us in a letter by Estonian lawyer PEETER ROOSMA in autumn 2013, Roosma warned us in letter that in case we do not submit this document the Application might not be considered at all. We had not idea it will be added to file and then quoted by Court as "expertise". After Roosma work at Human Rights Court ended he was named to join as judge to Estonian Supreme Court and is also EHRC add hoc judge in 2017.UN torture cases expert in Washington Post - Haloperidol Soviet era torture drug.